a study of chestnut trees

On Wednesday Sotheby’s sold a Van Gogh for $190.4 million, a record for him. The day before, the heirs of the man who sold it in 1936 settled their claim to it. The claim turned on whether he got a fair price. That question has a hole in it.

On 25 May 1890 Vincent van Gogh wrote to his brother Theo that he had finished “a study of chestnut trees.” He had left the asylum at Saint-Rémy nine days earlier and was living in Auvers-sur-Oise, outside Paris. The painting shows a chestnut in full bloom and a few figures on a path below it. He died two months later.

It went to Theo, then to Theo’s widow, Jo Bonger. A French prince bought it in 1905. In 1909 it went to Samuel Fischer, the Berlin publisher whose house printed Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse. After Fischer died in 1934 it passed to his daughter Brigitte and her husband, Gottfried Bermann Fischer, a surgeon who had married into the firm and ended up running it.

Then 1936.

That year Bermann split the publishing house in two. The books the regime would tolerate stayed in Berlin under Peter Suhrkamp. Bermann took the writers it wouldn’t tolerate to Vienna, under his own name. The family fled Berlin, and paid the Reich flight tax, the levy the Nazis used to strip departing Jews of their wealth. Three months later the painting, which had been on deposit with the dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt since 1932 or 1933, was sold in Amsterdam to a Paris couple, the Kapferers. The heirs’ research says the sale was forced by the losses the firm took under Nazi rule.

After that it moved the way paintings move. A Hollywood producer, Buddy DeSylva, had it by 1945. A New York collector had it in the 1950s. It was last shown in public at the Guggenheim in 1964. In 1975 the Blaquier-Arrieta family of Buenos Aires bought it, and they owned it for fifty-one years. It was the lead lot in their collection sale at Sotheby’s New York on 18 November, estimated at $180 million before fees. Van Gogh’s auction record, fees included, was $117 million.

On 12 November the heirs’ lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, wrote to Sotheby’s. The sale couldn’t go ahead, the letter said, unless the auction house showed the 1936 sale happened “at fair market value and independent of Nazi duress.” Sotheby’s answered that “our research to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress,” and that it was committed to “a mutually satisfactory resolution.”

Here’s the hole. A market price is what a willing seller and a willing buyer agree on, with either one free to walk away. In 1936 the seller had just fled his country with the half of his catalogue it wanted rid of, and paid a tax designed to take what he had. Whatever number the Kapferers paid, it was a price set by a man who couldn’t say no. You can’t measure “fair market value” in a market where one side has no exit. The test doesn’t have an answer, because the thing it’s testing for wasn’t there.

And here’s the turn. Bermann rebuilt his publishing house after the war, from Stockholm, New York and Amsterdam, and got it back. According to ArtDependence’s account of the claim, he never pursued the painting. His heirs pursued it the week it was about to become the most expensive Van Gogh ever sold.

The cynical reading is that the price summoned the claim. I think that’s true, and I don’t think it’s damning. The sale was exactly as unfair in 1960, when the painting was worth a fraction of this, and in 1975, when it changed hands in Buenos Aires. What changed is what the unfairness is worth. A wrong that costs a few thousand dollars to fix doesn’t get a lawyer. One that costs two hundred million does, and it was always the same wrong.

The family that owned it from 1975 did nothing wrong either. That’s why these cases tend to end in settlements and not verdicts: nobody living caused the harm, and everybody living is holding part of it.

This one did. On Tuesday, the day before the sale, Sotheby’s said the two families had reached “a mutually satisfactory resolution,” in recognition of “the suffering endured by the Fischer family during the Holocaust,” the Associated Press reported. Nobody disclosed the terms. On Wednesday the painting sold for $190.4 million with fees. Reuters, citing the New York Times, reported the buyer was the dealer William Acquavella.

So the 1936 price never did get measured. It got replaced by a new one, agreed in private this week between two families who could both walk away.

Van Gogh called it a study. That still fits. It’s a study of what a price means when one side can’t say no.


Sources: The Art Newspaper: the painting, the letter to Theo, provenance ↗ · The Jewish Chronicle: flight to Vienna, Reich flight tax, Sotheby’s response ↗ · ArtDependence: deposit with Feilchenfeldt, Schnabel’s letter, Bermann never sought the painting ↗ · JNS: sale forced by the firm’s losses ↗ · Artprice: Blaquier-Arrieta sale, estimate, $117m record ↗ · Gottfried Bermann Fischer, Wikipedia ↗ · AP via Spectrum News: the settlement, Sotheby’s statement, $190.4m ↗ · Reuters via WSAU: terms undisclosed, buyer per the NYT ↗