Franksgiving

In 1939 Franklin Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving up a week to give stores more shopping days, and the country split over which Thursday to eat on. Congress settled it two years later. Everyone remembers that as Congress putting the holiday back. It didn’t, quite.

For 1939 the United States had two Thanksgivings.

The holiday was younger than it felt. Sarah Josepha Hale, a magazine editor, spent seventeen years campaigning for a national day of thanks, starting in 1846. She wrote to five presidents: Taylor, Fillmore, Pierce, Buchanan and Lincoln. Lincoln’s 1863 proclamation is the one that stuck, and it fixed the day as the last Thursday of November. For seventy-six years, that was that.

Then November 1939 had five Thursdays. The last one was the 30th, which left twenty-four shopping days before Christmas, and the retailers hated it. Roosevelt had turned down the same request in 1933, the last time Thanksgiving landed on the 30th. This time Fred Lazarus Jr., who ran Federated Department Stores, made the case to him, and Roosevelt agreed. In August he said Thanksgiving would be a week early. His proclamation on 31 October named Thursday, 23 November.

The country didn’t take it well. Gallup found 62 percent against. Charles D. White, the mayor of Atlantic City, called it “Franksgiving.” Alf Landon, who had lost to Roosevelt in 1936, said it was another example of “the confusion which [Roosevelt’s] impulsiveness has caused,” sprung “upon an unprepared country with the omnipotence of a Hitler.” The selectmen of Plymouth, Massachusetts, where the whole story is supposed to start, disapproved. Colleges had football games scheduled for the old date, and some conferences only allowed games through the Saturday after Thanksgiving. Calendar makers, who printed years ahead, were stuck with the wrong Thursday in print.

The states couldn’t agree either. A governor proclaims Thanksgiving for their own state, so each one had to choose. By the count on Wikipedia, twenty-three states and the District of Columbia went with the 23rd, twenty-two kept the 30th, and Colorado, Mississippi and Texas gave the day off both weeks. Families split across state lines didn’t get the same holiday. Roosevelt did it again in 1940 and 1941, both times on the third Thursday.

Then the numbers came in. A Commerce Department survey, reported in the New York Times in May 1941, found no significant increase in retail sales from the change. Shoppers spent what they were going to spend anyway. The point of the whole exercise didn’t hold up.

So Congress stepped in. On 6 October 1941 the House passed a joint resolution making the last Thursday in November the legal Thanksgiving: Lincoln’s day, the one Hale had fought for. The Senate amended it. Its version said the fourth Thursday. Roosevelt signed that on 26 December 1941, and it took effect the next year. Texas held out on the last Thursday until 1956.

Most years, the fourth Thursday and the last Thursday are the same day, which is why almost nobody noticed the swap. But roughly two Novembers in seven have five Thursdays, and in those years the fourth one comes a week before the last. That’s precisely the move Roosevelt made in 1939, for precisely those years when it made any difference. The resolution everybody remembers as Congress undoing Franksgiving wrote Franksgiving into law. And it did it after the government’s own survey had shown the move did nothing for sales.

Hale wanted a day the whole country would keep together. She got one. But the date it sits on was finally set by an argument about shopping days, and the stores won it even though they hadn’t gained anything.

This year November has four Thursdays, so it doesn’t matter. In 2028 it will. Thanksgiving that year falls on 23 November, the same date as Franksgiving in 1939, and the last Thursday of the month will be the 30th. Nobody will call it anything.


Sources: National Archives: Congress establishes Thanksgiving ↗ · FDR Library: the year of two Thanksgivings ↗ · Franksgiving, Wikipedia ↗ · Sarah Josepha Hale, Wikipedia ↗ · Fred Lazarus Jr., Wikipedia ↗